Skip to content

Can Warren crash Massachusetts political gender ceiling?

September 15, 2011

Elizabeth Warren has become the latest woman candidate to try to crash the Massachusetts glass-ceiling of high state political office. Warren, a Harvard Law professor and noted consumer advocate announced her candidacy yesterday for the U.S. Senate seat now held by Republican Scott Brown.
Warren, 62, must win a primary but she seems to be the Democratic Party’s best candidate for Senate. She is smart, well-spoken and has a track record of fighting against Wall Street excess, which should make her a strong contender against Brown, who is arguably one of Wall Street’s favorite senators.

Warren will need money and lots of it. Brown is sitting on a re-election kitty of more than $10 million. But he won the seat in a special election against Martha Coakley, the Democratic state attorney general who ran a lackluster campaign. It was also a low-turnout affair; Brown received around the same number of votes that John McCain got in Massachusetts in the 2008 presidential campaign, where he was swamped by Barack Obama.

Brown toured the state in his pickup and courted an Everyman image. He is a personable, hail-fellow-well met jock who played basketball at Tufts. Brown is not known for his intellect and in recent months has shied away from tough media questions and famously flip-flopped on the Paul Ryan-Tea Party endorsed budget. He had Tea Party support, which may be a millstone in 2012, a presidential year in reliably Democratic Massachusetts, which of course was the lone state to support George McGovern against Richard Nixon in 1972. Massachusetts hasn’t voted for a GOP presidential candidate since Ronald Reagan’s 1984 49-state landslide.

Warren’s challenge will be to appeal to the street and make sure not to get tarred with the `Havahd’’ elitist label. She can do this because she has a good personal narrative – daughter of the middle-class, educated at a state university, spent her career as a fighter for average middle-class voters. But one never knows how someone who has never been elected to office will play under the relentless scrutiny of a high-profile U.S. Senate race where a candidate is expected to know about everything from the Glass-Steagall Act to the settlement issue in Israel to the ERA of  Josh Beckett.

The other factor at play is the role of independent expenditure groups. The U.S. Supreme Court’s Citizens United decision has opened the door to huge corporate financing, with scant disclosure, of political campaigns. These independent groups made big inroads in 2010 and helped Republicans win the U.S. House. Seasoned political operatives tell `On Politics’ that these groups will have much more money to spent in 2012 and will usher in a new era of campaign  financing that may be good for political consultants, television stations and pollsters but not so good for transparent government. This trend will likely hurt Democrats far more than Republicans who, after all, have always harvested the bulk of corporate PAC money.

The other climb for Warren is gender. Massachusetts is one of only two New England states that have never elected a woman U.S. senator or governor. The other is Rhode Island.

Still, if Warren can get $7-$8 million, win the primary and hire some good consultants, she ought to have a shot at a marquee Senate contest with big national implications because it is one of the few chances Democrats have at tipping over a GOP seat.

2 Comments leave one →
  1. al toke permalink
    September 15, 2011 8:03 pm

    She has a good resume, is obviusly not liked lke by national Republicans in the Senate who would not confirm her for the consumer chief post, and since when is being from “Havahd” a detriment for public office in Mass.,(ever hear of the Kennedys, Lodges, Peabodys etc.), all of which should recommend her to voters.

    I have seen her on TV with voters, she is smart and personable. If she raises the funds, and is willing to work until final election day (unlikel Coakley who was once the golden girl of Mass, politics) she can win. I do not think gender will be an issue.

    I salivate over the prospect of her being in the U.S. Senate among guys who would not confirm her !

    Good Luck Prof. Warren !

  2. September 15, 2011 8:12 pm

    Ruth Simmons is great ; the first and only Brown prsident to visit the inner city neigborhoods and provide resources and students to work with chidren. She is a freasure to our state.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: